Is this the genesis of pony meme?
John has developed an infallible way to improve any public policy wishes. You just wish for the thing, plus, wish that everyone would have their own pony!
This is two years old at this point which predates my usage of the ‘I want a pony’ phrase, however I found mention of it here: The 2001 perl advent calendar. It’s not the same thing, but clearly related. Metafilter predates that by a few months: July 9th, 2001.
Digging more however I find several pointers (Example) which explain why the phrase is so captivating. Because it was coined by a brilliant genius: Bill Waterson. Calvin and Hobbes is the source of “I want a pony”.
Had I bothered to read to the end of that original link I might have noticed this:
UPDATE: John wants me to point out that he got the idea from a Calvin and Hobbes strip in which little Susie first wishes that Calvin was nicer, then realizes she might just as well wish for a pony while she’s at it. So, thank that Calvin and Hobbes guy, or something.
Ooops. While I can’t find the actual strip anywhere here is a description of it I want a pony.
Makes me want to read some calvin and hobbes.